Why DRM really, truly sucks
November 29th, 2007 by Dan FuhryToday in a class I’m taking there was someone a couple desks down that has dyslexia. We have a bit of reading to do for the class, so he had gone and bought the e-book form of the book. Naturally the file was delivered in a DRM-protected format.
The fact is that this guy uses TextHelp Read and Write Gold for screen-reading. The way it works is, you select text, and the software reads the text to you in a way that’s a bit better than “Microsoft Sam” (you know, the speech engine that says “crow’s nest” when you feed it the word “crotch”?).
The problem with this e-book, and most others, is that copying text is not allowed. You see, according to the publisher, if you select text, you’re trying to copy it so that you can share the book with others, which violates the publisher’s rights and makes the author starve to death because he has to choose between paying the electric bills and eating dinner.
When this guy tried to select text so as to make Read and Write Gold read it, he received a message from Acrobat Reader informing him that the “publisher of the book doesn’t permit copying text.” Read and Write Gold didn’t work for him, and now reading this book is going to be about 5 times as hard.
Folks, we have a serious moral issue here. About 1 person out of 30 will have some sort of reading difficulty, most commonly dyslexia. It is absolutely imperative that all technology that we develop is accessible - and that means without DRM. Developing technology that restricts people with learning differences under the claim of copyright protection is cruel and immoral, not to mention just complete bullcrap. It’s absolutely impossible for a company like Adobe to provide test cases for absolutely every scenario where DRM would restrict use. Therefore, it should be quite obvious that we need to just DRM completely. Developing it costs money, licensing it costs money, implementing it costs money, and when your customers start seeing its effects and stop buying in DRM-protected formats, that’ll cost a buttload of money.
Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »